Game “review” – Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin

Game “review” – Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin
DARK SOULS™ II: Scholar of the First Sin

DARK SOULS™ II: Scholar of the First Sin

FromSoftware, Inc.

$39.99
View on Steam

PROs:

✅ Lot of unique mechanics (weight calculation effects, NG+3, Soul Memory, repeated hollowing, area state upping, enemy despawning, dynamic torch, roll complexity, fall damage scaling, unique items, quest lines, spell cost reductions, lack of I-frames, pvp in boss fights, reverse invasions, temporal summons, environment rewards in boss fights, item secret unique effects, and more)
✅ Huge weapon/armor/utility item pool and great fashion souls
✅ Very diverse build options
✅ One of the best PvP experiences in the Souls franchise
✅ Fast travel between bonfires
✅ Covenants can be maxed without doing PvP
✅ Charming hub zone
✅ Plenty of QoL features
✅ Some fun and funny PvE invasions
✅ 8-directional roll and smooth movement
✅ Magic is improved and made fun
✅ Power stancing
✅ A lot of content in general — the longest closed-world Souls game
✅ Meaningful NG+ changes

CONs:

❌ Nonsensical world design
❌ World design is aesthetically lackluster aside from the DLC areas
❌ Lackluster enemy and boss designs
❌ The Adaptability stat (tying I-frames and stamina consumption to leveling ADP)
❌ Lack of I-frames (can die opening doors or get hit while on the floor; great for PvP, horrid for PvE)
❌ SoFTS introduced nonsensical enemy placements and an overuse of stone statues
❌ Abyssal hitboxes (especially on grab attacks)
❌ Some enemies and bosses have horrible attack animations on top of bad hitboxes
❌ Less impressive OST
❌ Item durability (much better in SoFTS after the 60fps durability fix, but still ass)
❌ Overcrowded areas
❌ Lore is not as interesting
❌ Some absolute BULLSHIT, unfair enemies and areas
❌ They managed to make the “remake” worse than the original in certain aspects
❌ Tedious questlines and summoning requirements

Comments:

Replayed the game with the “Lighting Engine” mod and “Seeker of Fire 2.0” overhaul mod. HIGHLY RECOMMEND IT. It’s how I imagine DSII: SoFTS should have been in the first place—an improvement on every aspect of the game, both visual and gameplay. (made actually damn enjoyable re-play) Anyhow… figured I might as well write a review of the vanilla SoFTS experience.

FYI, I have a total of ~600 hours between the original and SoFTS combined. There’s a lot I don’t remember, so certain things are definitely left out of this review.

That said, first of all, it’s still an enjoyable, “good” game, but it’s the weakest out of the Dark Souls franchise. Whilst the game introduced a LOOOT of new, hidden, and unique mechanics alongside massive gearing diversity, it generally feels like an entirely different game than traditional Dark Souls (which makes sense, given I later found out it was made by another team with minimal involvement from Miyazaki). It simply lacks that unique world charm, storytelling charm, and combat feel.

Even so, it isn’t a bad game. Putting aside the mechanical quirks and QoL features, it genuinely has one of the best PvP experiences in the series, and co-op is fairly fun. It’s a game where I actually stuck with PvP for a while, tested a ton of random builds that somehow worked, and enjoyed great fashion souls. I discovered unique mechanics I hadn’t noticed until hundreds of hours in. Doing this game 100% was a long but fairly fun experience—though unlocking NPC items, completing questlines, and dealing with covenant requirements takes forever. Reaching NG+3 is basically where I finally got “everything.”

Story and world? Meh. I mostly didn’t care about the plot since the lore wasn’t very interesting, and the world layout was extremely odd. Level progression feels nonsensical, with very few visually stunning areas. The DLCs were a lot more intriguing in that regard, likely because Miyazaki was involved in their world design. Majula was a charming, chill hub, though.

Combat is a mixed bag. As I mentioned, PvP was great: diverse gearing, the ability to hit players during animations, parry them, hit while grounded, and surprisingly good netcode that meant you could actually land hits without dealing with endless lag-steppers. Magic builds are also much more viable, diverse, and fun.

Now… that exact same design philosophy is what made PvE suck. Being vulnerable to hits while opening doors or lying flat on the ground is simply not fun. The attack animations of certain enemies were extremely odd, making dodging, blocking, and parrying much harder than they should have been. And the HITBOXES—especially on enemy and boss grab attacks—were an absolute nightmare. Getting grabbed by a boss who lunges forward while you are standing entirely behind them because the hitbox spans a 100-meter radius IS NOT FUN.

Oh yeah, and you know what? Let’s make it even more “fun” by introducing the Adaptability stat, which you are forced to level just to get baseline I-frames and reasonable potion-drinking speed. What a cancer mechanic.

Also, SoFTS thought it would be a brilliant upgrade to just add random enemies everywhere for no good reason—a change whose only real purpose seemed to be enabling co-op chaos. While we’re at it, let’s add dumbass stone statues everywhere just to artificially cockblock your progress.

On another note, finishing questlines is rather tedious since you have to summon NPCs into boss fights and keep them alive. Gear durability is also pretty garbage; at least the durability fix means you no longer have to carry three sets of backup weapons just to travel from bonfire A to bonfire B.

Overall, whilst this game has a mountain of issues—many of which were actually introduced in the SoFTS release—it is still “good” per se. It has its own unique strengths and charms, but it’s weighed down by an equal amount of infuriating flaws.

FUCK THOSE ICE HORSES.

🟡Total score: 6/10👍

Game status:
✅ Finished
Reviewing info: How I review/rate & other info on my website through my profile. („desozone“)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *