Game “review” – Dark Souls Remastered

Game “review” – Dark Souls Remastered
DARK SOULS™: REMASTERED

DARK SOULS™: REMASTERED

QLOC

$39.99
View on Steam

PROs:

✅ Beautiful interconnected world
✅ Mysterious & dark storytelling / lore
✅ Fairly large gearing options
✅ Some QoL that original didn’t have
✅ Jolly Co-Op
✅ Challenging world and combat
✅ Epic Music and boss fights
✅ Aimless exploration and discovery
✅ Great NPCs

CONs:

❌ Age is starting to show compared to newer titles in the franchise
❌ 4-directional roll when locked on
❌ Very punishing to die
❌ Lot of grind needed if want to test various weapons maxed stat
❌ Armor upgrading material grind
❌ Bed Of Chaos vs gravity
❌ Quest-lines hard to follow
❌ PvP sucks balls
❌ Magic kinda eh..
❌ Traversal becomes eventually tedious
❌ PvP invasions & cheaters (charming when no cheater or lag hopper invades)

Comments:

First of all. At the time this game came out it was definitely a masterpiece and genre-defining. Over the years of sequels and similar games it still has its charm, but when it comes to visuals, combat, and especially QoL features, its age is starting to show. Nevertheless I still return to it now and then for different mod overhaul playthroughs. Also remember this is the remaster — PTDE would be even clunkier to play today. The remaster brought a lot of solid improvements. Still not as clunky as Demon’s Souls though.

Sadly it’s been a very long time so I don’t really remember my “first reactions / emotions” to this game. I’ve played the non-Steam PTDE version, steam version and the remaster with a total of roughly ~600 hours. Plenty of vanilla re-runs and mod re-runs.

It’s one of those games that reminded me why I like games. It was punishing as hell, but the awe of exploration and bosses was great fun. The oddly dark world with extremely confusing lore (I was watching a lot of lore videos back then just to understand the game better) was another big charm of it.

Combat is one of the most satisfying experiences in this game. You get screwed over a lot, you learn enemy patterns, the terrain, your weapon and so on, and eventually the difficulty becomes easier. That gives you incentive to try another weapon and then remember again how hard the combat is. Rinse and repeat. Though going back to Dark Souls 1 after the sequels really reminds you how damn infuriating the 4-directional roll is. In newer games you lock on and roll wherever you point the stick. Here you can only roll in 4 directions when locked on.

Magic is slow and clunky. It’s cool and strong with a proper build, but melee is much superior overall.

Death is punishing. Okay you lose your souls which isn’t a problem if you get back to your corpse… but because this game has large sections between point A and B (and some bosses), getting to your corpse alive is itself a challenge. The amount of times I’ve died just trying to sprint back to my corpse and getting shanked from behind is unreal.

World design, music and aesthetics were a masterpiece at the time. Beautiful grim world with challenging terrain and an epic soundtrack. The way zones are interconnected with shortcuts made exploration fun. Some secrets and unexpected shortcuts are also interesting. I played hundreds of hours before ever seeing a “Vagrant” mob… I was confused as hell.
Izalith shortcut as well.

Multiplayer features and co-op are also definitely interesting, genre-defining and fun. The bloodstains (seeing how other players died) and soapstone messages that give hints or troll you make exploration nicer (sometimes). Although co-op or being “human” comes with the risk of PvP invaders. Which was partially fun as long as you didn’t fight laggers or cheaters. But because of how common lag backstabs were, it lost its charm after a point. Especially if you’re a PvE player who just wants to co-op, it gets really annoying. And even to this day the game still has a fair bit of concurrent players.

Overall it’s one of the best games out there and genre-defining. Extremely challenging but rewarding. The amount of rage quits I’ve done and then returned to this game is unreal. Extremely infuriating moments and areas, but once you learn how to deal with them they become a cakewalk.

Likely forgot a few things to mention. But this wall of text is enough.

And FUCK Bed of Chaos and FUCK Tomb of the Giants.

🟢 Total score: 10/10 ✨

Game status:
✅ Finished

Reviewing info: How I review/rate & other info on my website through my profile. („desozone“)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *